Monthly Archives: oktober 2008

Abortion, a human right or a human rights violation?

I was watching the third, and final, presidential debate between Barack Obama and John McCain a little earlier. Among the various topics was abortion, and I just thought I’d put my two cents out there, for people to either use to form their own opinion, or send me hate mail over (By the way, you’ll end up in the spam bin, so don’t bother either way! You’ll just be wasting precious Internet bandwidth, and less importantly, your time).

I have a very “Danish” view on abortion, with a few elements of my own. In Denmark we have what we call “free abortion”, free meaning unrestricted. Until 12 weeks into the pregnancy, it’s the full choice of the woman, if she wants an abortion, no questions asked, she doesn’t even have to cite a reason or rationale for behind decision. After the 12th week, and until the 20th week, she has to get the approval of her her region’s abortion council (In Denmark, a region is an administrative unit). The later in the pregnancy, the stronger the arguments are needed, and they really have to be something extraordinary, not just “I fucked this guy, and I forgot to have an abortion earlier”. Girls who have gotten pregnant before they turned 15 (Which is the age of concent in Denmark), are almost always allowed to have an abortion, until the fetus is concluded to be viable, because the pregnancy was the result of illegal intercourse. In 2005, a 13 year old girl was allowed to have an abortion in the 20th week of the pregnancy, while a 15 year old was denied abortion in the 24th week, because it was presumed that the baby, that late in the pregnancy was viable.

I largely agree with this policy, although some details, such as the point in time, the 12th week, when unrestricted abortion is no longer allowed, I would like to have explained (If you are capable of this, please leave a comment!).

I don’t think human life is somehow “higher” or more special than say a whale or a shark for instance (By the way, people have found beer cans and other crap we dump in the oceans in the stomachs of tiger sharks, they clean up our mess!). And we kill many of those every darn day, some in exceptionally cruel ways, which I think would classify as torture-for-profit, “finning” is a good example, where you catch a shark, cut it’s fins off and throw it back in the ocean to die, solely to get the fins to make a bowl of tasteless soup.

Now, make no mistake, I believe in human rights, and very strongly at that. But I also believe, that the allocation of those human rights are important in the overall picture. I look at it from a timeline perspective. I think relatively unrestricted abortion (Like we have in Denmark), is fine until the point in the timeline of a pregnancy, when the fetus is definitely viable, and able to live independently on it’s own (I am not currently aware of what this point is, scientifically, if you happen to know, please leave a comment, but if you’re a crazy religious nut-job drone, please cut the fucking shit about life beginning at conception!). You often hear about people who were born early, but are completely normal despite that. When a fetus can both in theory, and practice “be born now”, so to speak, I think that’s a fair time to say “OK, now this is a human, who is entitled to human rights, such as the right to life and the right not to be tortured” (This last one I think certain leading people from the Danish Conservative People’s Party disagree with, since the latter wants to extradite detainees to countries that exercise torture. Talk about going over for tea, at the house of George W. Bush!). Before that time, when the fetus wasn’t able to live on it’s own anyway, I think saying to the mother “OK, even though your baby can’t live on it’s own, you are still gonna HAVE to go through with the pregnancy” is a violation of her human rights. To be specific, I think it’s a direct violation of article 4 of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) which says:

“No one shall be held in slavery or servitude; slavery and the slave trade shall be prohibited in all their forms.”.

I think you could argue, that saying to a woman that she HAS to go through with a pregnancy, which is a lot of effort on her part, and in many ways “work” as well, whether it being her family saying that or the state, classifies as a form of slavery. I also think that denying a woman abortion, when the fetus is not viable, and not able to live independently on it’s own, is a violation of article 25 of the UDHR which states:

Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control.”

(Emphasis by underlining is mine.)

Because it takes away the right of the individual, to have an adequate standard for well-being of him- or herself, and a pregnancy could dramatically impact that well-being.

After the point in a pregnancy, where a fetus is viable, and able to live on it’s own, then I think the allocation shifts, and says “OK, this is a human, which is deserving of full human rights”, which would be the right to life, which is specified in article 3 of the UDHR and the right not to be tortured specified by article 5 of the UDHR.

When fools are simply idiots!

Taking a good deal of interest in the US 2008 elections, for various reasons such as concern for the future, and a good laugh from classic comedy as well, I watched the vice presidential debate live through a CNN video stream. Not being either liberal or conservative (I’m a socialist!), I don’t really agree a lot with either side (Especially these general notions of “affording to go to college”, “affordable healthcare”, just make me laugh out loud!), but when the topic came to Iraq, I wish I could shake Joe Biden’s hand. I was about to explode at times!

First of all, one thing John McCain and Sarah Palin love to argue is that the US should not “surrender” in Iraq, and that “victory” is in sight, even though that the word surrender, in a military context means “to yield (land, a town, etc.) to an enemy.” (Source:, which is absolutely not what would happen if the US handed control of Iraq to, doh, Iraq!
Being both strongly opinionated and being Danish, I just can’t say this in other ways: BULL-FUCKING-SHIT !!!
This just shows a mountain of Republican idiocy!
First of all, the UN didn’t approve of the US going into Iraq, and at the same time, Iraq, under Saddam Hussein, had absolutely nothing to do with 9/11, in fact Saddam didn’t like al-Qaeda and Islamic fundamentalists in the first place, and hadn’t attacked the US at all, or done anything that in any way could justify military retaliation. So here we could talk for hours about whether the whole thing was a big-ass war crime (And yes I believe it was, and George W. Bush and Dick Cheney should be sent to the Hague, maybe they can chit-chat with a few guys from Serbia!). Secondly, it has been an absolutely horrendious humanitarian catastrophe. Over one million Iraqis, the vast vast vast majority being innocent civilians, have died as a result of the US invasion of Iraq in 2003, and if you ask me, George Bush’s oil-wet-dreams. Thirdly, the war in Iraq has been a ginormous strategic disaster. Complete and utter failure is what it has been. What the hell was the US thinking when they, in 2003, disbanded the Iraqi army, which they had full control over, even when an Iraqi general came to the Americans and said, that he could have thousands of troops on the streets of Iraq, to prevent plunder, and maintain law and order. Not only did this blunder cause many families to be robbed of all of their belongings, violence and other shit, but it also left thousands of men, whom had military training, without a job and without a means to care for their families, and at the same times, the militias were like “We can help you, go kill some Americans and we will make sure you can take care of your family”.

The stance of John McCain on the issue of Iraq, just shows incompetence and abysmal judgement beyond comprehension!

My country, Denmark, a NATO-ally and supporter of the ISAF effort in Afghanistan, has over 700 soldiers in Afghanistan. Now, that may not sound like a lot at all, especially compared to the US (Oh and by the way, US generals in Afghanistan are saying how they need more troops!!!), but I can tell you that for us, a small nation, it’s taken significant amount of resources. I’ve come to the conclusion that if the US doesn’t get their shit together in Afghanistan within a year or a year and a half, so that we can actually start hunting down al-Qaeda and make progress on non-military fronts, I say just pull out! Not because I am opposed to the war in Afghanistan, but because I am opposed to not accomplishing anything through it. It’s not worth wasting money and resources, and potentially lives, for absolutely nothing. At home we have problems with our welfare state that we need to fix, if our contributions to ISAF don’t make a difference anyway, let’s go home and spend the money where it does make a difference.
Unlike Iraq, I support the NATO effort in Afghanistan, which the UN has approved of by the way, I really really want this mission, which I believe is an important one, to succeed! But I don’t support incompetence, stupidity, neglect, idiocy and failure, which is pretty much all the US has demonstrated in Afghanistan! Because you know what, it’s not going well at all in Afghanistan, in fact it’s sliding towards chaos, al-Qaeda and the Taliban are not withering away, it’s going LOUSY!!! Which John McCain didn’t seem to get until somewhat recently.

Another thing that pisses me off, is that the world always seem to wait for the US to make a move on something. Darfur is one of the best examples of the world. We have a large-scale genocide taking place, and we’re doing absolutely nothing!! This brings shame on us all!
If the ship known as the United States of America sinks as a result of the economic crisis, or even if it doesn’t, I believe it’s time to take the European Union (Which I am a strong supporter of) to the next level. Why couldn’t Europe stand up and say “ENOUGH!” in Darfur, and end this genocide once and for all! This is about thousands of people’s lives, not whether some asshole named George W. Bush can fulfill his money-money wet-dreams of oil. Maybe I’m just angry tonight, but the thought of constantly having to say “We have to wait for America!” just pisses me off, when it comes to things that REALLY REALLY matter.

Copyright © 2005 - 2015 Troels Just. Alle rettigheder forbeholdes.